Table of Contents
There are two well-known brands in the payroll software industry: ADP and Gusto. However, they have distinct pricing points, complexities, and target groups.
ADP is a powerful platform that is widely recognized in the industry. It meets almost all administrative requirements, but its prices are not transparent, and you may need to set aside extra money, even for its small-business option, RUN. There is also a significant learning curve associated with ADP.
On the other hand, Gusto is a small business payroll software that is easy to use and intuitive, making it ideal for beginners. Its elegant user interface supports easy-to-use features.
These two popular names are not interchangeable as they serve different purposes. Find your ideal payroll match by reading on. However, the low-key strategy has a disadvantage, as it may be difficult to progress with this title.
Features comparison
User-friendly interface
Gusto is renowned for its easy-to-use interface and extensive offerings for small and medium-sized enterprises. It has features including health benefits administration, automated payroll runs, compliance support, and a set of personnel management tools.
These and other tools are provided by ADP. But only Gusto offers everything in a gorgeous point-and-click interface that doesn’t require any prior technical knowledge. In other words, it’s ideal if you’re craving something simple to use and headache-free.
Integrations
Because of its extensive network of connections, ADP has the best third-party integration capabilities. Everything is available for linking, including HR Avatar and Square. Furthermore, if your preferred program isn’t supported right out of the box, don’t panic. Almost any enterprise title can be synced up with the title via the Marketplace platform.
There are a few third-party connections in Gusto as well. In terms of quantity and quality, ADP is unmatched. Therefore, if you enjoy your current workflow, this world-renowned title will fit right in.
Employee Self-Service
Gusto can be helpful if you have a large number of past and current employees. It provides employees with lifetime access to its self-service portal, where they can check previous W-2s, pay stubs, and other documents.
In comparison, ADP offers a similar tool, but it can only view W-2s or 1099s from the past three years. Additionally, its user interface is not as simple and elegant as Gusto’s.
Scalable Plans
ADP is a highly scalable platform that can cater to your needs with its extensive range of features. It provides access to specialized HR experts through the HR Help Desk, manages State Unemployment Insurance (SUI), sends notifications for tax compliance, and offers an application tracking system. It is designed to assist companies of all sizes, from startups to large corporations, and excels in areas such as central payroll functions, customer service, personnel administration, and HR capabilities.
Furthermore, it provides more flexible support for global workforces, whereas Gusto solely provides employer-of-record services.
Customer Services
Gusto and ADP are equally dependable for companies in need of payroll and HR support because they both provide excellent customer service.
Phone help is available from 5 a.m. to 5 p.m. Pacific Time via Gusto. For questions that come in after hours, you can also use automated bots, email assistance, and live chat.
Similarly, live chat, email support, and automated help are all available from 7:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. Eastern Time for ADP’s U.S. clientele.
With the help of these platforms’ vast knowledge bases and instructional resources, users can solve problems on their own.
Thus, whichever choice you make is sure to please if you value top-notch customer service.
Target Audience
ADP Run is designed for small to medium-sized businesses, specifically catering to those with up to 50 employees. It offers essential payroll features, including direct deposit for employees and contractors. ADP Run handles federal, state, and local payroll taxes, and its employee portal provides access to pay history and up to three years of W-2s/1099s. While it’s suitable for smaller businesses, ADP Run can accommodate growth as companies expand.
On the other hand, Gusto primarily targets startup companies and small businesses in the United States. Known for its intuitive user interface, Gusto offers both automated and manual payroll options. It calculates and files federal, state, and local payroll taxes. Additionally, Gusto administers health, wellness, retirement, transportation, housing, and custom benefits. Notably, Gusto excels in customer support, making it an attractive choice for businesses without dedicated HR departments. However, its services are primarily tailored to the U.S. market and may not be as suitable for larger enterprises.
Scalability and Integration
When considering scalability and integration in human resource management software, both ADP and Gusto offer notable features. ADP stands out for its robust customization options, allowing businesses to tailor the software to their specific needs as they grow. Whether a company is a small startup or a medium-sized enterprise, ADP can accommodate changing requirements with its flexible framework, ensuring adaptability as employee count increases or the business expands.
ADP provides extensive integration options with other business tools, enabling seamless connections with existing HR systems, accounting software, time-tracking tools, and more. This integration not only streamlines processes but also reduces manual data entry, enhancing overall efficiency. On the other hand, Gusto’s scalability is highlighted by its well-designed user interface, which caters to businesses of all sizes.
While primarily targeting startups and small businesses, Gusto can handle increased payroll complexity and additional employees as a company grows. Though Gusto may not offer as extensive integration options as ADP, it focuses on providing a seamless user experience, ensuring that its features work harmoniously together. The platform integrates with popular accounting software, benefits providers, and time-tracking tools to facilitate efficient operations for businesses.
Gusto vs. ADP Pricing
ADP
ADP provides tailored solutions for various company sizes. However, the platform’s costs are highly variable, and its pricing isn’t publicly disclosed due to its ability to address complex and dynamic needs. To receive an exact quote, you’ll need to interact with a sales representative.
Therefore, RUN Powered by ADP, its small-business product, might not be the best choice for startups or smaller businesses because it supposedly has a greater price and complexity compared to other options in the market. However, larger businesses may find ADP’s offerings suitable, particularly if they intend to expand quickly.
Gusto
Compared to ADP, Gusto is more cost-effective for small and medium-sized enterprises and provides clear pricing. Monthly packages begin at $40 plus $6 for each employee; higher-level plans that include benefits management and additional services are at least twice as expensive. This pricing is comparable to rivals that cater to small businesses, such as Patriot Software.
However, Gusto has fewer features than ADP. For smaller organizations, it can handle their basic payroll and HR requirements. However, it won’t provide premium benefits like global expansion or intense analytics.
Advantages and Drawbacks
Gusto
Advantages
- interface that is easy to use.
- competitive costs.
- customized for small companies.
- many payroll functions, including benefits management, direct deposit, and automated tax filing.
- Excellent client support.
Drawbacks
- Restricted capacity to grow.
- Perhaps too easy for certain companies.
ADP
Advantages
- Scalable solutions.
- Extensive feature set that includes tax filing, benefits administration, compliance support, and sophisticated HR features.
- for administration, assistance with compliance, and tax filing.
- Availability of committed HR advisors.
- Worldwide payroll functionalities.
- Solid reputation along with dependability.
Drawbacks
- intricate pricing and plan details.
- Possibility of additional costs.
- may be too complicated for small companies.
- fees for each payroll run.
- Not available for free.
Which one is better?
If you are deciding between Gusto and ADP for your company, here are some factors to consider:
Choose ADP if you need a highly scalable solution that can grow with your company and requires an extensive set of features for payroll and HR. Additionally, if having access to in-depth customer support and committed HR experts is important to you, ADP might be the better option.
Choose Gusto if you have a small to medium-sized company and are looking for a reasonably priced payroll solution that is easy to use and set up. If you don’t need comprehensive HR services beyond payroll and basic benefits administration, Gusto might be a better fit.
